01月27日讯 在LG杯决赛的决胜盘中，柯洁因对争议判罚的不满选择退赛，这使得他被判负，而卞相壹则以总比分2-1获得冠军。赴韩跟踪报道此次比赛的《弈城围棋网》记者曲江在其文章中详细列举了两位韩国裁判的不当表现，并指出他们粗暴拒绝中国队合理申诉，使这场世界大赛变成了一场闹剧。
以下是记者曲江的观点：
本届LG杯决赛引发如此轩然大波，是我决定前往韩国进行现场报道时完全没有预料到的。在过去几天里，有关此事件的问题已在网络上引起广泛讨论。我不打算再重复关于规则合理性的问题，只想谈及两位韩国裁判在这一过程中所展现出的不当行为，可以说，他们难辞其咎，让这场世界大赛事变得滑稽可笑。
第一局：俞在星八段
第二局中的首任裁判为俞在星。当柯洁首次遭遇犯规指控时，我正好进入对局室（后续发生的再次犯规和第三局问题已经禁止媒体入内）。那时，柯洁与中国队总教练俞斌通过翻译向裁判提出了针对提子放入盒盖时间问题的申诉，但俞并未接受。他认为解释权属于自己，如果你们对此不满意可以事后投诉。这种态度显然非常强硬且缺乏尊重。
更让人震惊的是，在经过约半小时左右之后，俞竟威胁如果继续拖延将直接宣告柯洁败北。一听到这个消息，无论是刘瑞敏还是其他参与者都感到极大的诧异。对于一项刚实施不到三个月的新规定，不应剥夺选手充分陈述意见和请求说明细节的机会，更何况这是一次明显无理取闹式地拒绝申请，这是第一次出现这样的情况。
第二局恢复对局
*孙根气五段*. The second judge was Sun Gengqi, a five-dan. The Chinese Go Association publicly stated that "the timing of the referee's interruption was inappropriate and affected normal competition." However, many were unaware of an important detail: when Sun interrupted the match, China’s side suggested waiting for Bian Xiangyi to finish his move before addressing any potential infractions (as he faced a tough decision at that moment), but Sun insisted on immediate action.
I wasn’t in the room then, yet both Ke Jie and Yu Bin later shared this with me. I believe China's request was completely reasonable; however, as a ref, Sun ignored it entirely and chose an unreasonable time to pause play. It is no wonder Ke Jie confronted him angrily asking “Are you even a professional player?” This marks another instance where our legitimate appeal met with unwarranted rejection.
A point worth mentioning is that during these critical moments—specifically in both the second and third games—the referees intervened just as it became Bian Xiangyi's turn to make moves. In fact...
【*金志锡九段**】in South Korea recently published comments suggesting if Ke Jie had admitted his mistake immediately after being called out by referee Son Geung Ki while playing game three.... However... 【 *Korean media has failed….*】(The specific details about rules should be further elucidated especially regarding 'placing pieces into boxes,' which cannot simply be resolved within ten seconds.)
In conclusion,...
The Korean Go community seems determined to equate their refereeing protocol more akin toward sports like soccer or basketball—with absolute authority over interventions—which clearly undermines respect towards players & fails fundamentally against traditional chess principles!}This incident indeed casts shadows upon not only LG Cup finals but also reflects poorly on how organizational integrity could falter under pressure from regulations misapplied intentionally! A simple reminder remains paramount: “Referees are there primarily serve fairness—not dictate outcomes!”
发表评论